Tagged with music industry

The Politics of Listening

I purchased Andrew Bird’s “Noble Beast” on Amazon MP3 a couple of days ago.  It is one of the most expertly crafted rock albums that I have heard.

Today I am listening to a live recording of a Spoon show.  Spoon is not a brilliant band by any means, but their second record, “Kill the Moonlight”, is also in my top 10 best albums from cover-to-cover that I have ever heard.  Seriously, it is great.  Listening to “Kill the Moonlight” gives me goosebumps.  There are so many moments of innovative brilliance on the record.  It is a shame that they have so far been unable to recapture that magic on subsequent albums.

I think many bands, relationships, painters, writers, etc. experience similar moments of temporary brilliance.  That is why all of Kurt Vonnegut’s books are not as good as Bluebeard.  His brilliance is not omnipresent in his art, but make no mistake about it – Vonnegut was brilliant.  He has a library of material that greatly exceeds the art of N’Sync.  He was a pro.  A lifelong devotee to his art.

The Rolling Stones have made a career out of playing “Satisfaction” and “Sympathy for the Devil” – both brilliant songs.  But the majority of their work doesn’t deserve a second look.  Same with U2, Radiohead, and Bruce Springsteen.  Their longevity is based more on moments of long-lost brilliance than it is on any sort of art.  If anything, these bands do a disservice to their art by not mixing it up more.

So where does that leave me?  I don’t know.  I don’t have a hit, so it’s hard to say.  Put my best song on the radio with a promotional machine behind it, and we’ll see where we stand.  Brilliant songs don’t need airplay to be brilliant, but without airplay, nobody will know they are brilliant.  And airplay is more politics than it is music.  It is marketing and hand-shaking.

I wish we lived in a truly capitalistic world where the best music, hair gel, and cell phones would be the ones with the biggest reach.  But we don’t.

Tagged , , , ,

What We Can Learn from Mickey Rourke?

“I look at these guys like Matt Damon, George Clooney, Sean Penn – they’re all very bright, educated guys who understand that it’s a business and there’s politics involved. I wasn’t educated or aware enough. I thought I was so good I didn’t have to play the game. And I was terribly wrong.” – Mickey Rourke in City Pages interview

Mickey Rourke is a talented guy. So talented that he is up for consideration for the prestigious “Best Actor” award at this year’s Oscars. But as he points out in the quote above, talent isn’t everything. Sometimes I wish it was.

I watched my über-talented older brothers’ band, Juvenocracy (and later Spank!) toil in relative obscurity in Chicago for ten years before, in a final push towards catching a break, they moved to Los Angeles, where the band played for three additional years before calling it quits. The band’s music was amazing, they guys had personality, they had (and still have) talent, their vocal harmonies were the stuff of dreams. But they didn’t make it. And it wasn’t from lack of trying.

They lived together, practiced together, and sometimes ate together, devoting large chunks of time to their stageshow and songwriting. They played all the big clubs in Chicago and had a large following, locally. They could even command top dollar from the concert promoters who booked them. Yet they could not break through.

I don’t know why they didn’t break through to the masses. Surely, there have been thousands of bands like them who have had all of the pieces that make for a great band, yet have been unable to get that big record deal.


(above: photo of Juvenocracy/Spank! with yours truly on the right, taken in L.A. in 2001)

I’m not sure what it takes to break through, but the lesson to be learned from my brothers and from Mickey Rourke is that talent and hard work isn’t everything. To get into those mainstream distribution networks like MTV, radio, and Rolling Stone magazine, you need to be “discovered”. The weird thing about getting discovered is that, really, anyone with some connection to power can discover you. It could be the son or daughter of a record label exec, a friend of Best Buy’s Chief Marketing Officer, or a talent scout from a record label. It could be a girl who is friends with a movie star who convinced the star to give a listen to one of her favorite bands (this actually happened in the case of my brothers’ band).

Anyway, I say all this mostly to vent. On Saturday, I saw two of the finest performers I have seen in a while (Brianna Lane and Peter Mulvey) at a house concert in Minneapolis. These two relatively unknown musicians blew my mind in ways that Beyoncé never has. They were 10 times more entertaining than Justin Timberlake and posess more charisma than Lil’ Wayne.  Plus, their music was beautiful and succinct.

I would love to live in a world where people are recognized more for talent and hard work.  I would love to see Lane and Mulvey headlining the First Avenue mainroom together (although it was quite special to see the two of them play in Brianna’s living room on Saturday).  I read earlier today that the Beatles wouldn’t have gone anywhere if Brian Epstein hadn’t forced them to wear suits and develop that “clean” brand they had early on in their career.    When it comes down to it, the Beatles might have been another of those great local bands lost to history had they not been discovered.

So, I am happy that Mickey Rourke is getting his just do.  A master of his art, not to mention a natural talent, Rourke is the type of guy that should be in mass-produced movies (unlike certain stars of the “Spider Man” and “Star Wars” trilogies).

Tagged , , , ,

That Thing You Do!

While I am waiting for the noodles in my mac & cheese to cook, I am watching That Thing You Do! on Netflix.  I love this movie!  It’s the story of a 1-hit-wonder band called “The Wonders” and stars Tom Hanks with a great supporting cast.

YouTube Preview Image

The movie accurately portrays the prospects of making it big in the music biz as purely a combination of timing and luck.  That is, talent is secondary – a fact that is made aparent by the glut of pop stars puking in our ears at any given moment with their unartistic, cavity-inducing ear candy.  No offense to you pop stars out there.  There certainly is something to making successful pop music…but it is more machine than art.  I stand firm in the belief that any band, if played enough on MTV at the right time, will sell 1 million records.  When that corporate buzz machine gets kicking, there ain’t no stoppin’ it.

I would be lying if I said that my disdain for the music biz wasn’t partly due to jealousy.  Surely, I would have sold out long ago if fame had offered its ugly hand.  It would be quite an adventure to have millions of fans, wouldn’t it?

But, fame has not arrived at my door…yet.  So I plug along.  And, hey – It’s not that bad!

Tagged , , ,